poindexter-cottage Carlton Landing-Poindexter Cottage https://thelakestay.com/vacation-homes/properties/poindexter-cottage/

View Carlton Landing-Poindexter Cottage | A Carlton Landing Vacation Rental

Carlton Landing! Let the kids play at Firefly Park! Beautiful!

Welcome to Poindexter Cottage - 20 Firefly Lane

Beautifully decorated with 2 living areas and a fantastic outdoor space with a ping pong table in the back yard!

This is the epitome of a family-friendly home. With access to Firefly Park and an intimate dining area, the whole family is sure to be pleased! There are 4 bedrooms for ample sleeping space, especially the bunk room with space to sleep as many as 6 kids.

The downstairs master bedroom features a king bed, and a second downstairs guest room that features a queen bed. Upstairs, you'll find a bunk room equipped with full and twin bunk beds with trundles and the fourth bedroom has a queen bed. There is a downstairs living area as well as an additional second living room upstairs. The kitchen area has a dining room table that seats up to six. The home sits right on Firefly Park and has a fitting porch with wooden bench swing and additional seating. The backyard has its own private fenced in area with room to run, use the outdoor ping pong table and light up the charcoal grill.



- Primary Bedroom: King Bed, Private Bathroom

- Guest Bedroom: Queen Bed


- Guest Bedroom: Queen Bed

- Bunk Room: Full and Twin Bunk Beds with Trundles

Golf carts parked at the property are owners use only.

If you would like to rent a Golf cart, please contact Lakeside Motorsports at

All of our vacation rental homes at LakeStay are equipped with bed linens, bath towels, a starter supply of amenities, and a washer/dryer unit for your stay. Guests will have access to our community amenities: pool, hot tub, grills, and seasonal kayaks-paddle board rentals.

4 Bedrooms
3 Baths
Air Conditioning
Carlton Landing Fitness Club
BBQ Grill
Community Firepit
Community Grills
Community Hot Tub
Community Pool
High Speed Internet
Near Lake Eufaula
Outdoor Ping Pong Table
Sleeps: 12
Title is required
Name is required
Email is required
Check In Date is required
Review is required

Thank you for entering your review. The review will become available to the system shortly.

5 5

Overall Rating:

4.6 4.6
Family Vacation
Review Date: 08/04/2021
1 4 5
We had a wonderful family vacation at The Poindexter Cottage. The property itself was in great shape and we loved the location. It was a little tight in the downstairs living space/kitchen for our group of 11, but other than that we had a great time.
Manager Response:

Response from LakeStay, LLC

Thank You for your feedback. We are happy to hear you had a wonderful time. Come back and visit us soon.
Carlton Landing
Review Date: 06/29/2021
1 4 5
Overall this house was nice albeit a little tight in the kitchen/living room space compared to other homes we have stayed in on property. The beds were very comfortable, which is big for me. Even my kids thought the bunk beds were super comfy! The big lawn area was great for the kids and they had lots of fun using the ping pong table in the backyard.
The master shower could use a new shower curtain and there was no can opener in the kitchen. The decor was a bit random compared to other homes on property. We had 11 people staying here (3 different families) and it suited our needs just fine.
Manager Response:

Response from LakeStay, LLC

Thank you for the feedback. We are happy to hear you enjoyed your stay! Come back and visit us soon.
Christmas At Carlton Landing!
Review Date: 12/31/2020
1 5 5
Our family met at Carlton Landing for Christmas. We had 3 beautiful, fun-filled days! Our teens played volleyball, ping-pong, basketball, and football on the field on the field in front of our house. With warm sunny days it was close to perfect! Amon was great to work with, as she was ready to help with anything we needed.
Manager Response:

Response from LakeStay, LLC

We are so happy to hear you had a great time! Come back and see us soon.
Weekend getaway
Review Date: 10/06/2020
1 5 5
The location of this rental in firefly park was perfect for our crew! We also had fun playing on the outdoor ping pong table.
Great getaway!
Review Date: 08/03/2020
1 5 5
We shared Poindexter Cottage with some family friends. There was plenty of space for each of our families. Having the big green space right in front was great for our kids. And the house isn't far from the pools or the swim beach!
Name is required
Email is required
Home Phone is required

Your request has been sent. We look forward to meeting all your vacation needs!

Home fronts Firefly Park

View from Firefly Park

View of Firefly Park from front porch

Front porch swing

Front porch

Living Room

Living and Dining Room

Dining and Kitchen

Living and Dining Room

Kitchen and Dining


Master King Bedroom Downstairs

Master King Bedroom Downstairs

Master Bathroom Downstairs

Master Bathroom Downstairs

Downstairs Queen Bedroom

Upstairs Living Room

Upstairs Living Room

Upstairs Living Room

Upstairs Living Room

Bedroom Queen Upstairs

Bunk Room Upstairs

Bathroom Upstairs

Rear of house with ping pong table

Back of house

Rear Lane Parking