LakeStay Reviews | Carlton Landing, OK
Property name:
Carlton Landing-Magnolia EscapeTotal reviews: 8
Carlton Landing- Magnolia Escape
Amy D.
Stayed Aug 2025
Rating:
House was excellent! Everything was clean and well maintained!
Magnolia Escape
Stayed Aug 2025
Rating:
We really enjoyed our stay at Magnolia Escape. It was a good location, close to the beach, pools and town center. Although it was very hot and humid during our stay we still loved the front porch swing and the screened in porch. The beds were very comfortable and the layout was perfect for our family of four.
Great Getaway
Savannah K.
Stayed Dec 2024
Rating:
The home was very cozy and quaint. Was perfect for my little family. All the comforts of home were included. Would recommend to anyone.
No stress!
Stayed Nov 2024
Rating:
This is a lovely home! We enjoyed eating our meals on the screen porch and enjoyed working a puzzle on the front porch. What a relaxing time! The house is in excellent condition. The property management was super friendly and helpful.
First time visit to Carlton Landing
Stayed May 2024
Rating:
We loved our first visit to Carlton Landing and we can’t wait to go back. Magnolia Escape was perfect!
Perfect escape!
Jarrod B.
Stayed Oct 2023
Rating:
Great get-a-way for families! BEAUTIFUL location, super quiet, extremely relaxing. Our little family of 5 had a wonderful visit and we WILL be back!
Relaxing getaway
Kelly G.
Stayed Jul 2023
Rating:
We enjoyed the Magnolia Escape. It was the perfect size for our family of four. It was close to the Boulevard Pool and the food truck area. I recommend Mama Tig’s Pizza. Very delicious and reasonably priced! We also ate at The Meeting House a few times and it was great too. A few things to be aware of: 1) Even with the map in the app, we had a difficult time finding the home. 2) Between the construction and constant mowing, it was LOUD outside during the day. 3) Pots, pans and baking sheets inside the home aren’t in great shape. They were usable, but definitely could be upgraded. All and all still a wonderful place.
Wonderful getaway cottage
Stayed Oct 2022
Rating:
Wonderful getaway cottage close to the beach and pool!
Manager's response
Hello Claire, Thank you so much for your review. We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your stay at Magnolia Escape and look forward to your next visit. Thank You, LakeStay Team 918.316.3574
Property name:
Carlton Landing-Chelsea CottageTotal reviews: 9
Best Location in Carleton Landing
Rita M.
Stayed Aug 2025
Rating:
The Chelsea House was the perfect house for our family. It is less than two blocks to the largest pool in the addition. We were also less than two blocks from Tig's Pizza Place where the vendors set up on the weekend. My family stayed three nights, but my family wanted two more weeks!! We didn't really need a golf cart to get to anything, but we rented one the last day just for the kids.
The house had plenty of room for all eight of us. The master bedroom is on the ground floor and is very spacious with a large bathroom and great shower. The younger people stayed upstairs and shared a very large bathroom. The kids loved the space outside the bedrooms to play the video games. The sun room did not have any air conditioning, so we could not sit there, but we did use it to put our floats and pool toys. There is a nice patio area between the Chelsea House and the neighboring house (patio belongs to Chelsea House) and my husband and I enjoyed this shaded area in the mornings as a place to enjoy our coffee. However, there is no shade in the afternoons. The house was very clean and was well stocked with kitchen cookware. I do wish owners had left us more kitchen soap and more soap for the washing machine. There is not a convenience store close by, and it was just too far to drive in to Eufaula. There is a marina store that sells beer, drinks and chips.
This is one of the best houses you can stay in at Carleton Landing due to its location being close enough to walk to many features. We loved it.
Great Weekend and 4th of July
Bobby L.
Stayed Jul 2025
Rating:
Great extended holiday weekend. The location was exactly what we wanted with being so close to the action downtown and close to the lake pool. Parking was smooth right off the street, which was a concern initially, but I never had an issue. We were able to park a golf cart behind the rental next to the carriage house. Overall, the house was well equipped to support 3 kids and 4 adults. The furniture was like new, and everything looked great. Had plenty of kitchenware to cook and serve everyone.
As with any LakeStay rental, everything was as expected and had plenty of towels and etc. Greatly enjoyed the outdoor fireplace to cook s'mores and grill to cook burgers. The screened patio was the perfect start to the day with a cup of coffee.
