LakeStay Reviews | Carlton Landing, OK

Carlton Landing is a favorite destination in Oklahoma.

LakeStay vacation rentals have a diverse inventory of Carlton Landing lake lodging options. With so many vacation rental options to choose from, we have the ideal place for your next Carlton Landing getaway!

To better serve you, we have been collecting and posting guest reviews to better assist in selecting the perfect vacation rental. Read past LakeStay guest reviews to discover your perfect Carlton Landing vacation property. Once you’ve stayed, we’d appreciate your review to pass along your experience to others. As always, if you have any questions about a property, please contact us. Our experienced team knows every property and can assist with specific questions.

Property name:

Carlton Landing-Magnolia Escape

Total reviews: 7

Great Getaway

Savannah K.

Stayed Dec 2024

Rating:

The home was very cozy and quaint. Was perfect for my little family. All the comforts of home were included. Would recommend to anyone.

No stress!

Stayed Nov 2024

Rating:

This is a lovely home! We enjoyed eating our meals on the screen porch and enjoyed working a puzzle on the front porch. What a relaxing time! The house is in excellent condition. The property management was super friendly and helpful.

First time visit to Carlton Landing

Stayed May 2024

Rating:

We loved our first visit to Carlton Landing and we can’t wait to go back. Magnolia Escape was perfect!

Perfect escape!

Jarrod B.

Stayed Oct 2023

Rating:

Great get-a-way for families! BEAUTIFUL location, super quiet, extremely relaxing. Our little family of 5 had a wonderful visit and we WILL be back!

Relaxing getaway

Kelly G.

Stayed Jul 2023

Rating:

We enjoyed the Magnolia Escape. It was the perfect size for our family of four. It was close to the Boulevard Pool and the food truck area. I recommend Mama Tig’s Pizza. Very delicious and reasonably priced! We also ate at The Meeting House a few times and it was great too. A few things to be aware of: 1) Even with the map in the app, we had a difficult time finding the home. 2) Between the construction and constant mowing, it was LOUD outside during the day. 3) Pots, pans and baking sheets inside the home aren’t in great shape. They were usable, but definitely could be upgraded. All and all still a wonderful place.

Wonderful getaway cottage

Stayed Oct 2022

Rating:

Wonderful getaway cottage close to the beach and pool!

Manager's response

Hello Claire, Thank you so much for your review. We are so happy to hear you enjoyed your stay at Magnolia Escape and look forward to your next visit. Thank You, LakeStay Team 918.316.3574

Nice getaway!

Sara G.

Stayed Aug 2022

Rating:

Carlton Landing is a great midwestern getaway. Lake Eufala is a hidden gem, great for boating with all of the sandy beaches on the shore. The house was the perfect size for our family. We enjoyed our stay very much.
Due to all of the construction and the gravel roads, the exterior was very dirty. Areas of the home could use a better attention to detail - dirty blinds and baseboards, dusty shelves. But the areas that really matter were very clean (kitchen, showers, toilets etc.). I would recommend a more regular power wash to the two porches so they are more usable for renters!

Manager's response

Hello Sara, We are glad you enjoyed your stay with us. We appreciate you brining these items to our attention and we will take them into consideration. Best Regards, LakeStay Team

Property name:

Carlton Landing-Chelsea Cottage

Total reviews: 8

Great Weekend and 4th of July

Bobby L.

Stayed Jul 2025

Rating:

Great extended holiday weekend. The location was exactly what we wanted with being so close to the action downtown and close to the lake pool. Parking was smooth right off the street, which was a concern initially, but I never had an issue. We were able to park a golf cart behind the rental next to the carriage house. Overall, the house was well equipped to support 3 kids and 4 adults. The furniture was like new, and everything looked great. Had plenty of kitchenware to cook and serve everyone.

As with any LakeStay rental, everything was as expected and had plenty of towels and etc. Greatly enjoyed the outdoor fireplace to cook s'mores and grill to cook burgers. The screened patio was the perfect start to the day with a cup of coffee.

Fabulous home for family reunion

Leslie G.

Stayed Jun 2025

Rating:

Perfect layout for gathering of family of 10 + 3 littles. Some slept in another house nearby but this house had the space inc. sun room and large dining room table for hours of fun. Courtyard provided good space to monitor busy toddlers while outside. Loved the proximity to the pools, shops and great pizza restaurant. (Get it to go!) We barely scratched the surface of all to do there after 3 days.

Cozy but Spacious Haven!

Amy K

Stayed May 2025

Rating:

We loved our stay at Chelsea Cottage! It has a homey feel while still being spacious enough to hold quite a few guests. My favorite part was sitting outside on the side patio with the fire pit but the sunroom is a close second. When you do venture out, you’re within walking distance of everything. A great place to go and relax! Would 100% stay there again.